Absolutely,........no reason......
Ha ha .....ha, I am rolling around on the floor as I am laughing!
TANKS very much I needed that!
Ok,ok, you are absolutely right. lets not assume any thing, none at all ! ;
Tell me, did you assume that you got ALL the rust out of the 50 year old tank..... AND assume that its the end of it for the rust? ..... I could go on but I will finish with a story,
An old mechanic friend of mine once told me; "when I am buying an old car and see new parts on it, good chance somebody cares for the car"
True, there are many different parts you could replace or upgrade, but a gas tank is not JUST a part, not just some container you put gas in to make the car go!
its a part that could potentially put lives in danger, so it has to comply with many safety factors . there are many issues that lead to tank failure, for instance, being exposed to the elements from outside AND inside, compounded with age, damage....., could cause metal fatigue in the press welded seams and other areas which are not visible in a regular inspection.
It's a good idea to have a new tank, if you can afford it(just a couple hundred bucks) especially if you already have rust developing inside(which means the inner walls of the tank have lost their anti oxidation coating). For the sake of originality, you could keep the old tank, thats all.
And now, 2 picture if you please;
1) imagine a red Ferrari pulling into a mechanic's shop and after raising the car, an old gas tank is exposed underneath! (Also with slight curb damage to the tank)
2) imagine the same car on the hoist with a new gas tank and new lines!
Tell me, which car appears to look safer, and more presentable?
Also, I am not a gas tank dealer, a promoter nor a sales agent there of.