• Welcome to For E Bodies Only !

    We are a community of Plymouth Cuda and Dodge Challenger owners. Join now! Its Free!

engine idle/noise

KlsCuda

Active Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2024
Messages
27
Reaction score
10
Location
Maine
Hi everyone,

As always, I appreciate everyone's help. This community has been great as I work through the many issues with my Cuda.

What I have here is a mystery 440 6 pack. The guy I bought it from had no clue about the engine, so I have no idea is it has a big cam or anything done internally. What I do know is that it has a MSD6al and a holley electric fuel pump pushing 7psi, Hooker Comp headers, vacuum advance on the distributor is plugged off (as well as the carb port for it)


When I got the car it would fire up but not idle at less than 1200 rpm and even then, it was so rough the whole car would shake

I've replaced plugs, wires, cap, rotor, rebuilt the center carb (I plan to do the outboard carbs this fall). i've adjust float levels on all 3 carbs and set fuel mixture screws on center and front carb ( can't do the rear without taking it off the car, so that'll happen when I do the rebuild).
I've adjusted timing to what I think is about 15 degrees BTDC.

It will now idle around 900 RPM but there is a bit of surging when driving and some hesitation.

I can't tell if there is a miss but it's not very smooth and this engine/exhaust combination is so loud it's really hard to hear anything when driving over the exhaust(it's setup AAR style with side exhaust) and i'm pretty sure a big exhaust leak


I have a video of it idling so you all can hear what it sounds like: VLIX
 
Last edited:

Challenger RTA

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2018
Messages
3,245
Reaction score
1,708
Location
PA Flood city
Not that this is correct it just came to mind. Timing chain. More diagnosis is needed. Like vacuum reading, timing,compression test, leak down test, distributor wore? Check fuel pressure steady.

vacumm-reading.jpg
 
Last edited:

KlsCuda

Active Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2024
Messages
27
Reaction score
10
Location
Maine
I was concerned about timing chain, vacuum reading is around 8 at idle. no matter where I set timing or adjust fuel mixture I can't get it over 8-9. I haven't done a leak down test... i have no idea how to do this.

sucks working on mystery engine. I think it's been cammed.. but I have no idea what it is.
 

Xcudame

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
1,562
Reaction score
1,175
Location
Southeast Arizona
Just going by what I heard, it sounds like it has been over cammed and your response of 8-9 inches of vacuum supports this. Leak down test and compression test will definitely help diagnose the problem. Depending on what camshaft is in there, the mechanical advance most likely needs adjusting. When people unplug the vacuum advance, it's usually because the distributor hasn't been modified to work with the high lift high duration camshaft. No vacuum advance helps the problem, but if it's driven a lot on the street (is that your intention?) you're wasting fuel mileage and causing pre-mature engine wear. If you wind up getting into the timing chain, I'd go ahead and remove the intake and carbs and try and determine the camshaft lobe lifts are.
You're right, trying to tune an unknown engine combo is harder.
 

KlsCuda

Active Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2024
Messages
27
Reaction score
10
Location
Maine
Thanks for the info. Yes my intention is street driving.. hard and fast lol but street driving. I might take it to the local drag strip just for fun once in a while, but nothing serious.

I'll probably pull it all apart at some point
 

pschlosser

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2022
Messages
659
Reaction score
249
Location
Santa Rosa, California
A few thoughts:

In the video, the engine does sound as if it has a longer duration camshaft than what was factory original. This may mean the engine is not entirely original inside, and may have been rebuilt at least once.

I am often dubious of a someone selling a performance car, and having amnesia about the status and condition of the engine. For someone who both doesn't want to lie or tell you bad news, they may develop... amnesia.

With patience and help from this forum, I am confident you can discover what needs to be done.

Your vacuum at idle seems pretty low to me, but then, with longer duration cams, this is a common side effect. A smallish vacuum leak might effect the surging and stumble you're seeing when driving. There are several ways to test for vacuum leaks, and some methods are pretty easy.

Is your exhaust so loud you cannot hear the engine when driving? If so, this will make some things harder to hear and diagnose, like a spun rod bearing.
 

KlsCuda

Active Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2024
Messages
27
Reaction score
10
Location
Maine
A few thoughts:

In the video, the engine does sound as if it has a longer duration camshaft than what was factory original. This may mean the engine is not entirely original inside, and may have been rebuilt at least once.

I am often dubious of a someone selling a performance car, and having amnesia about the status and condition of the engine. For someone who both doesn't want to lie or tell you bad news, they may develop... amnesia.

With patience and help from this forum, I am confident you can discover what needs to be done.

Your vacuum at idle seems pretty low to me, but then, with longer duration cams, this is a common side effect. A smallish vacuum leak might effect the surging and stumble you're seeing when driving. There are several ways to test for vacuum leaks, and some methods are pretty easy.

Is your exhaust so loud you cannot hear the engine when driving? If so, this will make some things harder to hear and diagnose, like a spun rod bearing.
The "mystery engine" was a good negotiation point and I was able to talk him down on the price of the car significantly, so that's something .

The seller claimed that he bought the car this way several years ago, so he was not the one that did the work and doesn't know much about it. I have my doubts but either way I'm having a lot of fun working on it and driving it.

I've been searching for vacuum leaks but haven't been able to identify any yet... but I'll keep going at it.

The exhaust is quite loud and makes it hard to identify what other noises I'm hearing. I may have to quiet it down just to help diagnose things.

as always I appreciate all the feedback!
 

Challenger RTA

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2018
Messages
3,245
Reaction score
1,708
Location
PA Flood city
I'll save you some time. To find a vacuum leak use brake cleaner. I seen other use gasoline but I think brake cleaner is a bit safer. Here is someones video. .
 

Chryco Psycho

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2008
Messages
4,650
Reaction score
2,287
Location
Panama
SO what is the question ?
Vacuum reading at idle in gear will give you a idea of the cam size , the power valve probably needs to be changed so it stay closed at idle in gear so if you have 6" at idle you need a 3.5 PV , , you also need smaller air bleeds on the idle & probably the jet circuit which cannot be changed on 6 Pack carbs but inserting a wire & trapping it behind the squirter can help
 

KlsCuda

Active Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2024
Messages
27
Reaction score
10
Location
Maine
SO what is the question ?
Vacuum reading at idle in gear will give you a idea of the cam size , the power valve probably needs to be changed so it stay closed at idle in gear so if you have 6" at idle you need a 3.5 PV , , you also need smaller air bleeds on the idle & probably the jet circuit which cannot be changed on 6 Pack carbs but inserting a wire & trapping it behind the squirter can help
ok thanks for the suggestions. my question was.. since this is an unknown engine, does it "sound" ok to all of you. I've rebuilt engines and cars in the past, but I don't claim to be an expert so just looking for any direction or thoughts anyone else might have. obviously just listening to a short clip of an engine idle isn't enough to diagnose but thought I might get a few suggestions, which I did.
 

KlsCuda

Active Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2024
Messages
27
Reaction score
10
Location
Maine
Thanks everyone who replied! you've confirmed my thoughts and the ideas about how to proceed.

as always, this forum is great and I appreciate all the input.

I also have a popping through the exhaust only on deceleration. Some people say that flowmaster will do this and because of the AAR exhaust there is not enough "tailpipe" after the muffler. But I think it's probably a fuel issue... too rich .. or another sign of an exhaust leak
 
Last edited:

Old Mopar

Active Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2020
Messages
41
Reaction score
18
Please be carefull on whose advice you follow. There is nothing wrong with side exhaust as built and the popping sound is from your set up being way off. Go to the lift off hood playground web site, they have a guide for tuning six paks written a while ago that works well for most applications. I have 45+ years of six pak experience tuning so argue with me.

It looks like your carbs and engine are not set up properly hence the problems you describe, which btw is very common for the six pak. Some specialized tools are required or you will never achieve success. Once you have the set up correct the final tuning is not difficult. Most mistakes are improper baseline set up, over jetting, too cold operating temp & too much fuel pressure.
 

Challenger RTA

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2018
Messages
3,245
Reaction score
1,708
Location
PA Flood city
What I have here is a mystery 440 6 pack
All the above information is good. What I'm and others are suggesting find out the condition of the engine before you tear things apart. By going through the tests. Then you know where not to look and look. If not it a bigger guessing game or a complete rebuild. A vacuum fuel presser gauge a cheap enough to have around and a leak down tester. Maybe a friend has one! Not like you need a $1000-$5000 scanner. The only other tools you need is a little bit of you skill and these members here are very knowledgeable. with there help you can fix it. If there is the problem with the six pak is a little different critter a little different but the same. Sometimes something like that is better of left being sent out. And then it has to be set up properly.
 
Back
Top