I just replaced my rear interior panels and package tray just this past weekend. The rear panels were on-top. The rear panels fit, but are a bit wider than the originals, mine look similar to yours, I did force it into the corners more so there is less overlap. Looks like we got them from the same place. My fitment is tight every place except the notch just behind the rear window, if that bothers me, I'll find something to fill it. I still have the old panels if anybody is interested, they are in one piece, but sun baked and every incorrect fastener was used on them in the past. I'm never going to use them, but just can't bring myself to throw them away.